The Battle of the Best

James Hardie HardiePlank: The Fiber Cement Gold Standard
James Hardie is the name most associated with "fiber cement." Made from a mix of cement, sand, and cellulose fibers, it is engineered specifically for the regional climate.
- Engineered for Climate (HZ5® Series): In Chester County and Berks County, we experience the HZ5® product line, which is designed to resist freezing temperatures, snow, and ice. It won't shrink or swell despite the wild humidity swings in Lancaster.
- Non-Combustible: Unlike wood or vinyl, HardiePlank will not ignite when exposed to a direct flame, nor will it fuel a fire. This is a massive safety plus for homes in more densely populated areas like Downingtown or Coatesville.
- ColorPlus® Technology: This factory-applied, baked-on finish resists UV fading better than any field-applied paint. Your home will stay vibrant for years without the "chalky" look common in older vinyl.
LP SmartSide: The High-Performance Engineered Wood
While James Hardie is fiber cement, LP SmartSide is high-tech engineered wood. It takes the natural beauty of wood and bolsters it with the proprietary SmartGuard® process.
- Extreme Impact Resistance: LP SmartSide is incredibly tough against physical damage. Whether it’s a stray baseball in a Lititz backyard or a hail storm over Wyomissing, this siding resists dents and dings better than almost any other material.
- Fewer Seams: LP SmartSide comes in 16-foot lengths, whereas most other siding comes in 12-foot sections. This means fewer visible seams on your home, creating a sleek, high-end look that is especially popular on modern builds in Exton.
- Advanced Protection: Every wood strand is treated with zinc borate, resins, and waxes to ensure it is completely resistant to termites and fungal decay—two major concerns for PA homeowners with wooded lots.
Which One Should You Choose?
If fire resistance and a "stone-like" durability are your top priorities, James Hardie is the winner. If you want the most impact-resistant product with the fewest seams and a slightly faster installation, LP SmartSide is the way to go.
Siding FAQ for PA Homeowners
Q: Is LP SmartSide the same as fiber cement?
No. While they are often compared, James Hardie is fiber cement (mineral-based), while LP SmartSide is engineered wood (wood-strand based). Both are far more durable than traditional wood or standard vinyl.
Q: How often will I need to repaint?
James Hardie with ColorPlus® technology typically lasts 15+ years before needing a refresh. LP SmartSide, depending on the finish used, usually requires repainting every 5–10 years if not using a pre-finished option.
Q: Can these sidings handle the PA "Freeze-Thaw" cycle?
Yes! Both materials are designed to handle the expansion and contraction caused by our local weather. This prevents the cracking and warping that often destroys natural wood or cheap vinyl.
Q: Does new siding increase my home's value?
Absolutely. According to national "Cost vs. Value" reports, fiber cement and engineered wood siding replacements consistently provide one of the highest returns on investment (ROI) of any home improvement project, often recouping over 80% of the cost at resale.
Ready for a Transformation?
At DreamAway Exteriors, we don't just "slap on" siding. We provide a comprehensive exterior solution that protects your home from the inside out. Whether you’re in Lancaster, Chester, or Berks County, we are your local experts in premium siding.
Contact us today for a free estimate, and let’s find the perfect siding for your Pennsylvania home!




